The project has ended. Responsible critical thinking has not

07.10.2026  

More than 100 political scientists, sociologists, journalists and lecturers completed the ‘Critical Thinking During Elections’ programme run by the Academy of Ukrainian Press (AUP) and the Friedrich Naumann Foundation for Freedom (Friedrich-Naumann-Stiftung für die Freiheit). Tetiana Ivanova reflects on the training and responsible political choices in Ukraine.

Tetiana Ivanova

‘I’m sorry, but I have to leave. An air-raid alert. Guided bombs are heading towards the city. I’ll be back. I promise.’

‘My apologies. Poor internet. No electricity. May I keep my camera off today?’

‘I’m in a shelter. If I lose the connection, carry on without me. I’ll rejoin later if I can.’

This is how our events happen today. War keeps interrupting the timetable, cutting electricity and connections, forcing people into shelters. But it does not stop our desire to learn, think, argue, develop and plan a future.

I am sure many studies and books will be written about this remarkable Ukrainian phenomenon.

Today, though, we are talking about elections. How to hold them fairly and democratically after the war. How not to repeat our mistakes. How to untangle the motives behind earlier decisions. Why did we believe that particular person? Why did that phrase stay with us? Why did one image inspire trust and another rejection?

And, above all, how not to make the same mistakes next time.

Critical Thinking During Elections: what remains after the project?

AUP and the Friedrich Naumann Foundation for Freedom’s project has ended. More than 100 political scientists, sociologists, journalists and lecturers completed the programme.

Critical thinking does not end with a project. If anything, it feels as though we have only reached the next stage of this conversation.

What main conclusions did we reach with our participants?

We need to prepare for elections now

Once the official campaign begins, it may be too late. Political choices do not originate in the polling booth. Recognition develops much earlier, followed by liking and emotional trust. Only then comes the ballot paper. Elections effectively begin long before polling day.

A short political memory is one of our greatest vulnerabilities

Austrian expert Oksana Stavrou discussed this in an interview with me. We remember emotions very well, but promises, specific decisions, votes, earlier statements and how they changed over time much less well.

Without political memory, critical thinking is only doing half its job.

We still personalise politics strongly

A Razumkov Centre study conducted in November 2025 found something revealing: 93% of those wanting new political parties also wanted new political leaders. The Centre notes that citizens often imagine a ‘new party’ as a leader-centred political project built around an individual.

We therefore risk voting primarily for a person and a constructed image rather than an institution, team or consistent programme.

Source: Razumkov Centre, ‘Ukrainian Citizens’ Attitudes Towards Political Forces, the Need for New Political Forces and New Politicians’, November 2025.

‘Hollywood politics’: image and emotion instead of difficult answers

What we might call ‘Hollywood politics’ is not going away. Charisma. The image of ‘one of us’. Recognition. A strong emotion. A carefully constructed hero. A simple message instead of a complex answer.

Ukrainian political strategist Denys Bohush also drew attention to image and emotional perceptions in our interview. The scenery will change, but not necessarily the mechanisms.

Social media and generative AI are changing the scale of political influence

The greatest change in future campaigns concerns the platforms spreading political techniques as much as the techniques themselves. TikTok. Telegram. YouTube. Recommendation algorithms. Generative AI. Personalised content.

Political influence is becoming faster, more precisely targeted and less visible to those it targets. This is already more than an abstract threat. In a September 2024 Rating Group survey commissioned by the EU Advisory Mission Ukraine, 89% considered disinformation a serious problem. Fifty-three per cent named social media as its main source; another 35% named messaging services, including Telegram.

Source: Rating Group for EUAM Ukraine, ‘A Success or Not? How Ukrainians Assess Law Enforcement Reform and EU Support’.

Our old political weaknesses may acquire an entirely new technological scale.

We may again await our ‘Knight Swift-Rail’, ‘Fairy Forest-Guardian’ or ‘Sage Ironbeard’ – characters from our final educational game.

Next time, however, the hero may be created by algorithms as well as political strategists. Their biography may be embellished, popularity artificially amplified, ‘popular support’ simulated and videos generated. Their promises may prove another political mirage.

What should we do?

Keep developing critical thinking. Test political memory against facts. Examine politicians’ earlier decisions as well as their words. Look beyond the leader to the team, and beyond an attractive programme to whether it can be delivered.

Demand professional scrutiny and verification from journalists rather than retransmission of political theatre.

Above all, learn to notice the moment when our political choice is only beginning to form.

The project has ended. Responsible critical thinking has NOT.

My sincere thanks to our committed participants, my wonderful co-trainer Nataliia Ponomarenko, the AUP team and, of course, the Friedrich Naumann Foundation for Freedom for supporting our bold initiatives and letting us discuss today what society needs to prepare for now.

Based on Tetiana Ivanova’s original Facebook post.

Translation note: This is a literary translation into British English, produced and proofread using a language model. Read the Ukrainian original.

"AUP-info" multimedia online media 
(identifier in the Register of Entities in the Media Sector: R40-00988).
envelopetagclockmagnifiercrossmenuchevron-uparrow-leftarrow-right